Since 1974, the Hall of Fame has been led by Scotty Carmichael (1974-78), John Bulmer (1978-80), Michael Jackson (1980-2002) and Mark Rich (2002-Present)

The Hall of Fame – Board of Governors are shown on the adjacent photo taken prior to the October 2020 Induction Ceremony: Dave Chandler (Selection Committee Co-Representative), Mary Anne Scudder, Dave Labelle, Marie Stephenson, Jim Malley (Selection Committee Co-Representative), Sandy Cunningham, Mark Rich (Chairman).

The Board of Governors shall appoint a Selection Committee consisting of one representative of the Board of Governors and eight (8) honoured members in the Collingwood Sports Hall of Fame.